| Year |
Name |
State |
| 1952 |
Rosemarie Bowe (replaced) |
Georgia |
| 1959 |
Sue Simone Ingersoll (withdrew; replaced) |
New Mexico |
| 1960 |
Cathy Justice (replaced) |
Ohio |
| 1965 |
Unknown (disqualified; replaced) |
Delaware |
| 1965 |
Bunny Baxter (replaced) |
Nevada |
| 2005 |
Sloan Bailey (replaced) |
Nevada |
| 2007 |
Katie Rees (dethroned; replaced) |
Nevada |
| 2007 |
Ashley Harder (resigned; replaced) |
New Jersey |
| 2008 |
Christina Silva (erroneously crowned; replaced) |
California |
